The new ribs are quite obvious, and did not seem less so as I looked at it more. So, I decided to go the stain route. I chose Minwax Early American stain that seemed pretty close. I stained the ribs (white cedar) but chose to keep the new planking (western red cedar) natural - there does not seem to be as much color variation there, and I think the red cedar will darken more and blend reasonably when varnished.
Below is the (unvarnished) finished product. As you can see, the stained ribs are a bit browner and do not have the yellow tinge of the old ribs. But, overall, I think it is a pretty good match. We'll see how it looks varnished!
The first coat will be thinned 50% - mainly to seal the wood. I plan to do this inside and out. (this will be the only sealing for the planking - instead of linseed oil or other treatments discussed on the canoe heritage web site.) Below is a pic of the first bit I have done. I am planning to work rib by rib to try and avoid seams and overlapping coats. I could not get the brush into the very front - hopefully the old treatment is sufficient to keep the bow and stern from rotting... I am not planning to varnish the gunnels at this point - I will do them all at once when the outer gunnel is installed. This will be after the canvas is on so will be a while.
That's about it for now. Hopefully varnishing will not take too long and next post will not be too far in the future. I may need to use the blog to collect my thoughts for figuring out how to get the canvasing done.
Oh yes, a few more prices:
medium (100) sandpaper - lots but out of my stash...
stain - about $6.00 (I really do not recall)
varnish - $45.00.
brushes, etc - so far only from stores...